Electric water heater: repair or replace?
Not heating, tripping the breaker, dripping or rusty? Answer four questions about your electric water heater (termoacumulador) and see whether it most likely needs a repair or a replacement, with the honest reasons and what to do now.
Repair or replace the water heater?
Question 1 of 4
How old is the water heater?
The date of manufacture is usually on the label (the plate with the brand and the litres). If you can't find it, think of when it was installed.
What brand is it?
The name is on the front of the heater or on the label.
What is it doing?
Is the size still right for the home?
For example, the family has grown and the hot water runs out halfway through a shower.
Likely result
This is a guide, not a diagnosis: the final answer comes once we have seen the label and the heater.
How the tool decides
Three things decide whether a water heater is worth repairing: where the fault is, how old the heater is and which brand it is. The tool weighs them in that order, because the first one can settle the answer on its own.
- Water from the body of the tank means replace. Inside every termoacumulador is a steel tank. When water comes out of the tank itself, or rust runs down it, the tank has almost always rusted through from the inside. No patch lasts on a tank that has corroded.
- The safety valve is a small repair. A few drops from the valve while the heater warms up are normal: the water expands and the valve lets the extra out. A constant drip means a worn valve or mains pressure that is too high. The valve sits on the cold water pipe, outside the heater, so we replace it whatever the brand, and fit a pressure reducing valve when the pressure needs one.
- Over about 10 to 15 years, usually replace. That is the normal life of an electric water heater in Lisbon, where hard water wears the anode away. Repairing one part of an old heater is usually followed by the next fault.
- Repairs only on the brands we work with. We repair Vulcano, Bosch, Junkers, Baxi and Vaillant, where we know the parts. Other brands, including Ariston and Teka, are replaced rather than repaired, because on simpler models a repair is rarely worth it.
The size counts too. If the hot water runs out halfway through a shower, replacing a heater that is a few years old with the right size often makes more sense than repairing it. Our water heater size calculator works out the litres for your home.
Symptoms and what they usually mean
| What you see | Usual cause | Usual answer |
|---|---|---|
| Not heating | Heating element or thermostat | Repair, if the heater is not old |
| Breaker trips | Shorted element, or damp in the cover | Repair, unless water is getting into the tank area |
| Drips from the safety valve | Worn valve or high mains pressure | Repair, any brand |
| Water from the tank body | Tank rusted through | Replace |
| Rust on the tank | Corrosion from the inside | Replace |
| Cracking or bubbling noises | Limescale on the element and the bottom | Clean and new anode, if the heater is not old |
The tool gives the likely answer, not a diagnosis. If yours is a gas esquentador rather than an electric tank, it is not covered here; our guide on a water heater not working explains the difference, and we repair and replace those too.
Before you send us anything
If water is coming from the heater, switch it off at the fuse box and close the cold water valve on the pipe going into it. Do not try to drain it yourself, and never block the safety valve. Then take a photo of the label, the plate with the brand, model, litres and date: it answers most of our questions before anyone comes out. Add a photo of the whole heater and the space around it, and a short video of any drip.
Repairing or replacing your water heater
We repair and replace electric water heaters, fit a new safety valve and take the old heater away. We also install one you have already bought. You get a written quote on WhatsApp, and no work starts until you approve it.
Related service: Water heaters and boilers
Electric water heater: repair or replace?
Can a leaking electric water heater be repaired?
It depends where the water comes from. A dripping safety valve or a leaking connection can be repaired. Water coming from the body of the tank means the tank has rusted through from the inside, and then the answer is replacement.
How long does an electric water heater (termoacumulador) last?
Usually about 10 to 15 years. Lisbon's hard water wears away the magnesium anode that protects the tank, so a heater whose anode is never checked tends to corrode sooner. Past that age, replacing is usually the better choice.
Which water heater brands do you repair?
We repair Vulcano, Bosch, Junkers, Baxi and Vaillant. On other brands, including Ariston and Teka, we replace rather than repair. The safety valve and the pipe connections are outside the heater, so we change those whatever the brand.
Why does my water heater keep tripping the breaker?
Usually a heating element that has shorted or damp under the bottom cover. Leave the breaker off and do not keep switching it back on. If water is getting into the cover, it can be the start of corrosion in the tank.
Do you take the old water heater away?
Yes. When we replace a water heater, we disconnect the old one and take it away. We also install a heater you have already bought.
Talk to a plumber
4.9 on Google. We fix it properly or we come back for free.
Leave your number, we WhatsApp you in under a minute.
WhatsApp and phone
Message us on WhatsApp at +351 21 700 9237 or call +351 21 700 9773.
4.9 on Google
Read what our customers say in our Google reviews.
English-speaking
1,000+ expats served across the Lisbon area.